When it’s hip to be responsible

The Tanzanian Federation for Home Economics teaches women to grow and harvest sweet potatoes to make chips like these.

I spent a weekend in Bonn, Germany covering a United Nations conference on sustainability as part of a team of student journalists. The conference was eye-opening for me, as I’ve never been involved in a UN proceeding before; overall, it seemed somewhat disorganized and too policy-oriented for my taste, but I think that’s just United Nations operation (at least policy orientation; I’m not sure about the disorganization).

I made a few friends involved with youth organizations in Germany and other parts of Europe. I spent lunch one day talking with some young people who work with Micah Challenge and YMCA Germany (rather different from YMCA in the USA) about the pros and cons of “environmentalism” as a trendy movement.

On one hand, this falls into a category one friend defined as a “first-world problem,” which is basically code for “a ridiculous argument you wouldn’t have if you didn’t already have your basic needs met well.” And even to the extent it is a “problem,” it’s a good one to have; at least the people who buy into the trend are making consuming efforts to do things like recycle and buy environmentally-friendly vacuum cleaners and even, sometimes, buy Tumbleweed Houses.

However, I wonder what this trendiness does to the environmental cause as a whole. I’m sure there are more people like me who are reluctant to define themselves by anything (I, like many of my college cohort, am almost allergic to defining myself by a church denomination. And you have to nearly drag the descriptor “Christian” out of me sometimes). I have no real desire to be one of “THOSE people” who don’t shower, flush their toilets with dirty dishwater and (true story) skin road kill squirrels on their back porches and eat them because they don’t like waste. I ride my bicycle when I can because it saves money, I recycle because various roommates have made me feel guilty for not (which I now appreciate) and I use reusable grocery bags (sometimes) because I can’t stand plastic bags spilling out of my closet when I open the door. But beyond this utilitarianism, I can’t think of a time when I did something to conserve energy, water, waste or food — certainly not anything that made me uncomfortable.

One part — and a large part — of this reluctance is just that I’m lazy and like comfort whenever possible. But part, too, is my label allergy. If conserving natural resources were just a thing everyone did — in Germany, apparently one is fined for not recycling, which makes sense to me, though I don’t really want to argue politics — I wonder how the dynamics of conservation in the US would change?

What do you think? Is this a semantic hang-up that doesn’t make much difference or does the trendiness of environmentalism make a difference, good or bad?

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “When it’s hip to be responsible

  1. It might be that the environmentalism trend favours especially visible and presumably costly approaches towards a sustainable lifestyle. Buying organic food, toxic-free clothes and hybrid automobiles is just a re-interpretation of the old status-through-consummation logic. By the way, Berlin Prenzlauer Berg is considered the epicenter of this lifestyle in Germany. You are right, I do not want to be labelled as one of those. Then there are the likes of people living in Eco villages, who really mean to pursue a carbon-free lifestyle. This is great, but their back-to-nature approach, often mixed with a decent dose of esoterics is as well something that does not appeal much to me. The only way to make those labels disappear is to work for the trend going mainstream, so the trendy people have to watch out for the next big thing.

  2. I stumbled upon a funny description today: pudding-vegetarians. The very ones who don’t eat meat or fish due to ethical reasons – therefore being hip – but they consume nontheless: sweets and finished products. Hey, they can be organic too.
    Being labbeled comes with a price: money and/or socially. The price of being constantly reminded – by yourself, your roommates, your friends, and ha!, even Jesus – that you want to do something. Without being labbeled. Just doing it because it’s right to save energy, to ride your bike, to buy fairtrade coffee and so on.

    I hope that being responsible isn’t just connected to the environmentalism trend. But it is the one that can be apealling. And hip.

    Let’s shake this thing of.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s